Character Education in Digital-Based Islamic Religious Education: A Systematic Literature Review of Student Learning Outcomes
Keywords:
Character Education, Affective Outcomes, Islamic Religious Education, Higher Education, Systematic Literature ReviewAbstract
Character education is an important orientation of Islamic Religious Education (PAI) in higher education, particularly amid the digitalization of learning. However, the affective learning outcomes reported in the literature do not fully demonstrate the connection between understanding values, appreciating values, and translating them into behavior. This study maps the affective learning outcomes of digitally mediated PAI in higher education and examines their alignment with Lickona’s character education framework, comprising moral knowing, moral feeling, and moral action. A systematic literature review was conducted following PRISMA, using Google Scholar through Publish or Perish. Of 996 initial records, 86 articles met the inclusion criteria and were analyzed through thematic content analysis based on textual evidence. The findings show that moral feeling appeared in 91.9% of articles, moral knowing in 89.5%, and moral action in 60.5%; 59.3% addressed all three components. Responsibility (55.8%) and cooperation/collaboration (51.2%) were the most frequently reported affective outcomes, whereas religiosity appeared in 34.9% and gratitude in only 4.7% of articles. These findings indicate that affective outcomes are more frequently represented through general character dispositions, while behavioral enactment and specific Islamic values receive less consistent attention. This pattern reflects the distribution and strength of evidence in the reviewed literature, rather than proving that digital learning directly causes character development. The review provides a basis for aligning learning objectives, instructional activities, and assessment in digitally mediated PAI with all three components of character education.