Effects and Risks of Projectization in University-Government-School Cooperation: Evidence from China

Authors

Keywords:

U-G-S cooperation, Projectization, Practical effects, Multiple risks, Chinese context

Abstract

Within China’s project-based governance system, the projectization of University–Government–School (U-G-S) cooperation has become a dominant mode of educational collaboration, reshaping teacher education partnerships and basic education reform. However, its governance implications remain underexplored. This study examines the formation logic, practical effects, and structural risks of projectized U-G-S cooperation in the Chinese context. Using a qualitative institutional analysis approach, the research integrates policy document analysis, theoretical interpretation based on project-based governance, resource dependence, and path dependence theories, and illustrative case evidence from existing literature. The findings indicate that projectization enhances precision, resource mobilization, and procedural standardization through time-bound cycles and performance-based evaluation, thereby improving the operability of cooperation. At the same time, it generates structural tensions, including goal alienation, path dependence, and the amplification of regional disparities resembling a Matthew Effect. These tensions stem from the dominance of instrumental rationality embedded in technical governance. This study provides a systematic institutional interpretation of both the benefits and inherent constraints of projectized U-G-S cooperation and offers insights for optimizing governance design in policy-driven educational systems.

References

An, F. H., & Wu, F. (2011). Cooperation between universities and primary and secondary schools: Policy guidance is the key [大学与中小学合作: 政策引导是关键]. Basic Education, (12), 75–79, 92.

Guan, X. M. (2022). Project system: Technical choices for modernization of national governance—A perspective of technical politics [项目制:国家治理现代化的技术选择——技术政治学的视角]. Journal of Gansu Administration Institute, (5), 87–102, 127.

Huang, J. X. (2018). On the dilemma and transformation of U-S cooperation [试论U-S合作的困境与转型]. Educational Review, (1), 58–61.

Li, W., & Cheng, H. Y. (2014). Obstacles and conditions for the success of U-S style school reform [U-S式学校变革成功的阻碍及条件]. Journal of Higher Education Research, (6), 68–75.

Li, X., Mei, Y., & Cheng, L. (2022). The research origin, core functions, and future prospects of U-S cooperation [U-S合作的研究缘起、核心功能与未来展望]. Road to Success, (7), 40–44.

Ma, Y. P., Ou, L. S., & Jin, B. (2011). From bilateral to trilateral cooperation: A new exploration of school improvement models—Taking Tiedong District of Anshan City as an example [从双方合作到三方合作:学校改进模式新探索——以鞍山市铁东区为例]. Journal of the Chinese Society of Education, (4), 25–28.

Pfeffer, J., & Salancik, G. R. (2006). The external control of organizations: A resource dependence perspective (R. Yan, Trans.). Oriental Press. (Original work published 1978)

Project Management Institute. (2009). A guide to the project management body of knowledge (PMBOK guide) (Y. Wang & B. Zhang, Trans.). Publishing House of Electronics Industry.

Qu, J. D. (2012). Project system: A new national governance system [项目制:一种新的国家治理体制]. Social Sciences in China, (5), 113–130, 207.

Shi, X. H., Geng, G. D., & Li, H. (2014). A new interpretation of path dependence theory [“路径依赖”理论新解]. Economist, (6), 53–64.

Song, C. X., & Lu, D. K. (2023). Reconstructing the university-school teacher partnership community [重构“大学-中小学”教师伙伴关系共同体]. Higher Education Development and Evaluation, (7), 105–113.

Wang, J. Y., & Cheng, L. (2011). U-S cooperation and the construction of diversified models: Also on the fifth Cross-Strait and Four Regions Academic Seminar on School Improvement and Partnership [U-S合作及其多元化模式建构——兼述第五届两岸四地“学校改进与伙伴协作”学术研讨会]. Research on Education Development, (20), 39–43.

Wu, L. P. (2018). Historical retrospect and realistic choice of U-S cooperation: Taking the cooperation between Taiyuan Normal University and Jinyuan Street Central School as an example [U-S合作的历史追溯与现实选择——以太原师范学院与晋源街道中心学校的合作为例]. Teaching and Management, (2), 44–46.

Xie, G. X. (2021). Research on the U-G-S teacher education training model based on grounded theory [基于扎根理论的教师教育U-G-S培养模式研究]. Higher Education Exploration, (12), 47–52.

Published

2026-05-25

Issue

Section

Articles